A Bit Of Un-Masked History

Comparisons have been made more than a few times between today’s coronavirus pandemic and the pandemic of 1918 known as the Spanish Flu.  Turns out that one of the issues we are grappling with today, mask-wearing, was a big issue back then, too.  I thought this bit of history from the New York Times was quite interesting!

The Mask Slackers of 1918

As the influenza pandemic swept across the United States in 1918 and 1919, masks took a role in political and cultural wars.

christine-hauserBy Christine Hauser

Aug. 3, 2020

Updated 12:29 p.m. ET

flu-1The masks were called muzzles, germ shields and dirt traps. They gave people a “pig-like snout.” Some people snipped holes in their masks to smoke cigars. Others fastened them to dogs in mockery. Bandits used them to rob banks.

More than a century ago, as the 1918 influenza pandemic raged in the United States, masks of gauze and cheesecloth became the facial front lines in the battle against the virus. But as they have now, the masks also stoked political division. Then, as now, medical authorities urged the wearing of masks to help slow the spread of disease. And then, as now, some people resisted.

In 1918 and 1919, as bars, saloons, restaurants, theaters and schools were closed, masks became a scapegoat, a symbol of government overreach, inspiring protests, petitions and defiant bare-face gatherings. All the while, thousands of Americans were dying in a deadly pandemic.

1918: The infection spreads.

The first infections were identified in March, at an Army base in Kansas, where 100 soldiers were infected. Within a week, the number of flu cases grew fivefold, and soon the disease was taking hold across the country, prompting some cities to impose quarantines and mask orders to contain it.

By the fall of 1918, seven cities — San Francisco, Seattle, Oakland, Sacramento, Denver, Indianapolis and Pasadena, Calif. — had put in effect mandatory face mask laws, said Dr. Howard Markel, a historian of epidemics and the author of “Quarantine!”

Organized resistance to mask wearing was not common, Dr. Markel said, but it was present. “There were flare-ups, there were scuffles and there were occasional groups, like the Anti-Mask League,” he said, “but that is the exception rather than the rule.”

At the forefront of the safety measures was San Francisco, where a man returning from a trip to Chicago apparently carried the virus home, research archives show.

By the end of October, there were more than 60,000 cases statewide, with 7,000 of them in San Francisco. It soon became known as the “masked city.”flu-2“The Mask Ordinance,” signed by Mayor James Rolph on Oct. 22, made San Francisco the first American city to require face coverings, which had to be four layers thick.

A ‘pig-like extension of the snout’

Resisters complained about appearance, comfort and freedom, even after the flu killed an estimated 195,000 Americans in October alone.

Alma Whitaker, writing in The Los Angeles Times on Oct. 22, 1918, reviewed masks’ impact on society and celebrity, saying famous people shunned them because it was “so horrid” to go unrecognized.

“The big restaurants are the funniest sights, with all the waiters and diners masked, the latter just raising their screen to pop in a mouthful of food,” she wrote.

When Ms. Whitaker herself declined to wear one, she was “forcibly taken” to the Red Cross as a “slacker,” and ordered to make one and put it on.flu-3The San Francisco Chronicle said the simplest type of mask was of folded gauze affixed with elastic or tape. The police went for gauze masks, which resembled an unflattering “nine ordinary slabs of ravioli arranged in a square.”

There was room for creativity. Some of the coverings were “fearsome looking machines” that lent a “pig-like aspect” to the wearer’s face.

Mask court

The penalty for violators was $5 to $10, or 10 days’ imprisonment.

On Nov. 9, 1,000 people were arrested, The San Francisco Chronicle reported. City prisons swelled to standing room only; police shifts and court sessions were added to help manage.

“Where is your mask?” Judge Mathew Brady asked offenders at the Hall of Justice, where sessions dragged into night. Some gave fake names, said they just wanted to light a cigar or that they hated following laws.

Jail terms of 8 hours to 10 days were given out. Those who could not pay $5 were jailed for 48 hours.flu-4The ‘mask slacker’ of San Francisco is shot.

On Oct. 28, a blacksmith named James Wisser stood on Powell and Market streets in front of a drugstore, urging a crowd to dispose of their masks, which he described as “bunk.”

A health inspector, Henry D. Miller, led him to the drugstore to buy a mask.

At the door, Mr. Wisser struck Mr. Miller with a sack of silver dollars and knocked him to the ground, The San Francisco Chronicle reported. While being “pummeled,” Mr. Miller, 62, fired four times with a revolver. Passers-by “scurried for cover,” The Associated Press said.

Mr. Wisser was injured, as were two bystanders. He was charged with disturbing the peace, resisting an officer and assault. The inspector was charged with assault with a deadly weapon.

In Los Angeles, ‘To Mask or Not to Mask.’

That was the headline for a report published in The Los Angeles Times when city officials met in November to decide whether to require residents to wear “germ scarers” or “flu-scarers.”

Public feedback was invited. Some supported masks so theaters, churches and schools could operate. Opponents said masks were “mere dirt and dust traps and do more harm than good.”

“I have seen some persons wearing their masks for a while hanging about their necks, and then apply them to their faces, forgetting that they might have picked up germs while dangling about their clothes,” Dr. E.W. Fleming said in a Los Angeles Times report.

An ear, nose and throat specialist, Dr. John J. Kyle, said: “I saw a woman in a restaurant today with a mask on. She was in ordinary street clothes, and every now and then she raised her hand to her face and fussed with the mask.”

In Illinois, the right to choose, and to reject.

Suffragists fighting for the right to vote made a gesture that rejected covering their mouths at a time when their voices were crucial.

At the annual convention of the Illinois Equal Suffrage Association, in October 1918, they set chairs four feet apart, closed doors to the public and limited attendance to 100 delegates, the Chicago Daily Tribune reported.flu-5But the women “showed their scorn” for masks, it said. It’s unclear why.

Allison K. Lange, an associate history professor at Wentworth Institute of Technology, said one reason could have been that they wanted to keep a highly visible profile.

“Suffragists wanted to make sure their leaders were familiar political figures,” Dr. Lange said.

‘Four weeks of muzzled misery’

San Francisco’s mask ordinance expired after four weeks at noon on Nov. 21. The city celebrated, and church bells tolled.

A “delinquent” bent on blowing his nose tore his mask off so quickly that it “nearly ruptured his ear,” The San Francisco Chronicle reported. He and others stomped on their masks in the street. As a police officer watched, it dawned on him that “his vigil over the masks was done.”

Waiters, barkeeps and others bared their faces. Drinks were on the house. Ice cream shops handed out treats. The sidewalks were strewn with gauze, the “relics of a torturous month,” The Chronicle said.

The spread had been halted. But a second wave was on the horizon.

By December, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors was again proposing a mask requirement, meeting with testy opposition.flu-6Around the end of the year, a bomb was defused outside the office of San Francisco’s chief health officer, Dr. William C. Hassler. “Things were violent and aggressive, but it was because people were losing money,” said Brian Dolan, a medical historian at the University of California, San Francisco. “It wasn’t about a constitutional issue; it was a money issue.”

By the end of 1918, the death toll from influenza had reached at least 244,681, mostly in the last four months, according to government statistics.

1919: A new year

In January, Pasadena’s city commission passed a mask ordinance. The police grudgingly enforced it, cracking down on cigar smokers and passengers in cars. Sixty people were arrested on the first day, The Los Angeles Times reported on Jan. 22, in an article titled “Pasadena Snorts Under Masks.”

“It is the most unpopular law ever placed on the Pasadena records,” W.S. McIntyre, the chief of police, told the paper. “We are cursed from all sides.”

Some mocked the rule by stretching gauze across car vents or dog snouts. Cigar vendors said they lost customers, though enterprising aficionados cut a hole in the cloth. (They were still arrested.) Barbers lost shaving business. Merchants complained traffic dropped as more people stayed home.

Petitions were circulated at cigar stands. Arrests rose, even of the powerful. Ernest May, the president of Security National Bank of Pasadena, and five “prominent” guests were rounded up at the Maryland Hotel one Sunday.

They had masks on, but not covering their faces.

The Anti-Mask League.

As the contagion moved into its second year, so did the skepticism.

On Dec. 17, 1918, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors reinstituted the mask ordinance after deaths started to climb, a trend that spilled over into the new year with 1,800 flu cases and 101 deaths reported there in the first five days of January.

That board’s decision led to the creation of the Anti-Mask League, a sign that resistance to masks was resurfacing as cities tried to reimpose orders to wear them when infections returned.

The league was led by a woman, E.J. Harrington, a lawyer, social activist and political opponent of the mayor. About a half-dozen other women filled its top ranks. Eight men also joined, some of them representing unions, along with two members of the board of supervisors who had voted against masks.

“The masks turned into a political symbol,” Dr. Dolan said.flu-7On Jan. 25, the league held its first organizational meeting, open to the public at the Dreamland Rink, where they united behind demands for the repeal of the mask ordinance and for the resignations of the mayor and health officials.

Their objections included lack of scientific evidence that masks worked and the idea that forcing people to wear the coverings was unconstitutional.

On Jan. 27, the league protested at a Board of Supervisors meeting, but the mayor held his ground. There were hisses and cries of “freedom and liberty,” Dr. Dolan wrote in his paper on the epidemic.

Repeal came a few days later on Feb. 1, when Mayor Rolph cited a downturn in infections.

But a third wave of flu rolled in late that year. The final death toll reached an estimated 675,000 nationwide, or 30 for every 1,000 people in San Francisco, making it one of the worst-hit cities in America.

Dr. Dolan said the story of the Anti-Mask League, which has drawn renewed interest now in 2020, demonstrates the disconnect between individual choice and universal compliance.

That sentiment echoes through the century from the voice of a San Francisco railway worker named Frank Cocciniglia.

Arrested on Kearny Street in January, Mr. Cocciniglia told the judge that he “was not disposed to do anything not in harmony with his feelings,” according to a Los Angeles Times report.

He was sentenced to five days in jail.

“That suits me,” Mr. Cocciniglia said as he left the stand. “I won’t have to wear a mask there.”

47 thoughts on “A Bit Of Un-Masked History

  1. Pingback: A Bit Of Un-Masked History – Laura Illustrates

  2. Pingback: Mask Mandates In US History - SteveZ MaskZ

  3. An interesting and informative column! In 1905 in “The Life of Reason” the philosopher and writer, George Santayana wrote : “Those who cannot remember history are doomed to repeat it.” In 1948 Winston Churchill in a speech to the House of Commons said a more well know paraphrase of that quote : “Those who fail to learn history are condemned to repeat it.” A quote often attributed to Mark Twain : “History never repeats itself but it does rhyme.”…disappointingly, if only to myself, is only partially accurate. Twain co-authored a novel in 1874 with a neighbor, Charles D. Warner, titled “The Gilded Age : A Tale of To-Day” and in the introduction wrote : “History never repeats itself, but the Kaleidoscopic combination of the pictured present often seem to be constructed out of the broken fragments of antique legend.” In essence each of the above are saying that if we do not learn from the history of the 1918 Spanish Flu, we too will pay the price…apparently we have not and we are!! Thank-you!

    Liked by 5 people

    • I must admit to scratching my head at the Mark Twain quote and wondering what the heck he meant! Rhymes … with what? Mystery? Blistery? But moving on … yes, we failed miserably at learning from the past and are paying a high price, yet some still insist on having their way, to the detriment of the nation. Sigh.

      Liked by 1 person

      • I could attempt to explain what Twain meant except for the fact that he never said it in the first place. Then again, who am I to suggest that I have entry into or knowledge of how the brilliant mind of Mark Twain worked? However, since you asked and being that for nearly four decades I repeated the nonexistent quote as I was completely enthralled with it on a personal level…I shall be so bold as to propose my theory! By the simplest definition the word “rhyme” is the correspondence of sounds between words or the ending of words. True, that most often is seen in poetry, but bear with me for a moment. Correspondence means a close similarity, connection or equivalence. So, I postulate that in this nonexistent Twain quote the word rhyme was not used in reference to actual poetry but rather to the similarity and connection of events in our personal world or the world at large. Hence, while any history does not exactly repeat itself…it does have similarities and connections to previous events. Such as the 1918 Spanish Flu and the 2020 Covid-19 in more ways than one, as the shared column clearly shows! Thank-you!

        Liked by 1 person

        • As you already know from my morning music post … glad it made you giggle, by the way … you and Mark Twain are talking above my head and making it spin 😵 … like a whirlpool … 🌀! Nonetheless, you make me smile. 😊


  4. I hope we never get an Ebola pandemic or some Black Death that hit Europe centuries ago and no means to cure it, as it’ll kill off millions…because people will not comply for their own good. Too obstinate and too selfish.

    Liked by 5 people

    • This nation has always encourage the independent spirit. In most things, that is good … really good. But, every now and then it backfires, and these days some have taken their “right” to be independent and do as they please a bit too far, thereby stepping on the rights of us all.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Individualistic, dangerous behaviour then and now ~ nothing changes. However, let’s not forget that the majority of people then and now are doing the right thing, wearing masks for the good of us all.

    Liked by 3 people

    • We fail to learn from past mistakes, and in this country there are far too many who bristle at being told what to do, even when it’s for their own good! It doesn’t help, of course, when our ‘leaders’, the people who are supposed to set the example, are an equally stubborn lot who are more concerned with their own image than our lives. Sigh.

      Liked by 2 people

  6. Jill, an epidemiologist professor who was asked to be on a Bush pandemic preparedness team, was interviewed on NPR. He studied the 1918 Flu epidemic, and said it was mishandled. He said in the interview, mission one in a pandemic is tell people the truth. The federal government failed to do so then, and failed to do so now. If people are told the truth, then asking them to do their part is less burdensome. Keith

    Liked by 4 people

    • Somehow it seems that telling the truth is very difficult for politicians these days, and not only here in the U.S. While most leaders have done better, there’s Bolsonaro, and even BoJo has dropped the ball and is promising his people that everything will be back to normal, bright and rosy, by Christmas. We fail to learn from our forefathers mistakes.

      Liked by 2 people

      • Jill, the two incumbents you mention from Brazil and UK are renowned for being untruthful. The Brexit vote planners chose not to involve Johnson in their efforts because of his lack of credibility. Bolosonaro is similar to the US president with his nationalism, bigotry, corruption and lying. Keith

        Liked by 2 people

  7. In 1976 I did an extensive family history involving the research of courthouse, church and local history records at the library. Many of my ancestors from that time period (families with 8 to 10 children) suffered great loss due to that flu. The church cemeteries placed small stones as markers for the family’s children many of whom were young teens when they died.

    Liked by 4 people

    • How sad. Bad enough when anybody dies, but when children die it is heartbreaking. How long did it take you to do that project, Larry? Sounds like quite an in-depth study. Sadly, as with most things, we haven’t learned a damn thing since then. We have better information, knowledge, can convey information worldwide with the click of a button, but people still don’t listen.

      Liked by 3 people

      • I worked a short walk from the courthouse dungeons where the records were stored and the library which had a wonderful county biographical section. Over a summer of lunchtime study, I was able to amass most of the history. Fortunately, all my ancestors had immigrated to Penna. in early colonial times and the available records provided a blueprint to my genealogy.

        Liked by 1 person

        • Yes, you were fortunate! My ancestors were scattered from coast to coast and would not likely be found in any single library. I considered doing a similar search using Ancestry at one time, but I simply don’t have the time. Maybe someday.

          Liked by 1 person

          • It was well worth the time and effort – gave me a new respect for the sacrifices of the Brauns and Schneiders. My people escaped from persecution in the Palatine area of present day Germany to England where the Queen gave them passage to the colony of New York as indentured workers with a guarantee of land and citizenship at the end of 7 years. The governor of NY reneged on the deal and they then rafted the headwaters of the Susquehanna River into Penn’s Woods establishing communities in present day Berks County. Not Amish nor Mennonite, they became known as Pennsylvania Dutch.

            Liked by 1 person

    • Well, one would like to think that with the ability for instant communication, the survival rate would have been much better … but we’re proving the fallacy in that thought process here in the U.S.!

      Liked by 4 people

    • True, it was … but if the U.S. keeps on as it has been, the coronavirus may end up being just as deadly. Today, we have better knowledge, better equipment … and yet, we have failed to learn from the lessons of history. 💕

      Liked by 2 people

Comments are closed.