Your Money Or Your Life???

Three-time Pulitzer Prize winner Thomas L. Friedman’s OpEd in yesterday’s New York Times needs no introduction, for it speaks for itself.  We would all do well to listen to what he says.

Trump’s Motto: Your Money or Your Life

The president claims you have to make a choice, but you don’t.

thomas-l-friedman-thumbLargeBy Thomas L. Friedman

Opinion Columnist

Whenever I talk about Covid-19 or climate change with skeptics, I use a simple analogy: Imagine that your child is sick with a disease and you decide to take her to 100 different doctors to get multiple opinions — and 99 doctors give you the same diagnosis and prescribed treatment and one tells you that there’s nothing to worry about, that your child’s disease will “disappear … like a miracle, it will disappear.”

What parents in their right minds would follow the advice of the doctor with the one-out-of-100 diagnosis?

This, alas, is no hypothetical. This, alas, is actually the most important question facing voters in choosing our next president. Are you ready to trust your own child’s and the country’s health to the guy who holds the one-out-of-100 view on both climate change and Covid-19? He being Dr. Donald Trump, founder of Trump University, where he apparently earned a B.S. in B.S.

It is stunning to me how many conservatives want to go with the doctor with the one-out-of-100 diagnosis, since doing so is anything but conservative. It’s Trotskyite radical.

And to riff off Trotsky for another moment, Republicans may not be interested in Mother Nature, but Mother Nature is interested in them. Both climate change and Covid-19 have brutally elbowed their way into our lives in the past year, and for the same reason: We have been stressing our ecosystems to their limits and beyond.

We’ve done this by invading wilderness areas and extracting wildlife carrying viruses never borne before by human beings and by emitting CO₂ that is heating the planet, amplifying storms that brought four months of rain in four hours in Florida and wildfires of epic proportions to the West Coast.

Joe Biden wants to proceed with more caution, and Trump wants to throw caution to the wind. That’s why the widely respected science journal Scientific American did something last week for the first time, declaring: “Scientific American has never endorsed a presidential candidate in our 175-year history — until now. The 2020 election is literally a matter of life and death. We urge you to vote for health, science and Joe Biden for President.”

The choice could not be more stark or important. Trump’s implicit motto when it comes to Covid-19 and environmental protection is always the same: Your money OR your life?

Which do you value more? Biden’s motto has been your money AND your life — you should not, and do not, have to choose between them, if we are wise and follow science.

How so? On Covid-19, for Trump, it’s jobs or masks, opening school or masks, social distancing or Big Ten football, science or church. Everything is black or white. And so is the result: So many Americans are jobless today and watching their kids learning remotely from home because Trump pitted masks against in-classroom schooling, masks against jobs, masks against indoor restaurant dining and masks against gathering for church services.

And too many Americans chose jobs and school and church out of desperation, and they’ve already paid the price or will pay it.

Biden, by contrast, is a unifier. He’s argued that if everyone wears a mask, practices social distancing and gets tested, we can BOTH protect many more jobs AND protect many more lives. Masks are not at war with jobs; they are the driver and protector of job growth in a pandemic. Masks are the vehicle to opening schools and other indoor activities — not their enemy. Just ask the Germans, Singaporeans or South Koreans.

Ditto when it comes to the environment and climate change. Trump wants everyone to believe that protecting nature means unemploying people. It’s clean air OR economic growth. It’s gas guzzlers OR unemployment. He’s forever pitting jobs against nature.

Biden stands for the unity of jobs AND the environment, the unity of jobs AND mitigating climate change. A clean, green economy equals better health AND more and better jobs. And the beauty is this: All that Biden has to do to prove his point is read aloud from the business and science pages:

Oct. 15, New Scientist: “The green economy has grown so much in the U.S. that it employs around 10 times as many people as the fossil fuel industry — despite the past decade’s oil and gas boom.”

June 30, “Tesla Inc.’s market value has surpassed Exxon Mobil Corp.’s in a sign that investors are increasingly betting on a global energy transition away from fossil fuels.” Tesla makes electric cars, batteries and solar products.

Aug. 25, CBS News: “Exxon Mobil, which joined the Dow Jones Industrial Average in 1928, is being removed from the blue-chip stock market index. Its replacement: enterprise software company”

April 6, Recharge: “Renewables accounted for nearly three-quarters of global power capacity additions last year — half of which was switched on in Asia, according to latest figures from the International Renewable Energy Agency.”

Sept. 17, Fortune editor Alan Murray: “Lululemon C.E.O. Calvin McDonald told me yesterday his company now has more U.S. stores closed due to environmental risk — fires in the West, hurricane in the Gulf, etc. — than due to Covid-19.”

If climate change turns out to be a less serious problem than predicted, and we pursue all of the above anyway, we will be like an athlete who trains for the Olympics, but the Olympics are postponed. No problem. We’ll just be that much healthier. Our air will be cleaner, our industries and vehicles and homes and industries will be so much more efficient and our economy will be the world leader in the clean power technologies that every country will want to import from us — climate change or not — as we add nearly a billion people to the planet by 2030. Yes, there will be nearly one billion more people on the planet in 10 years.

On the other hand, if we treat climate change like a daydream and it proves to be a nightmare, we will be in real trouble as a species.

So, I hope Biden goes into next week’s debate and just says: “My fellow Americans, you don’t hire an arsonist to put out forest fires. You don’t hire a divider to heal racial wounds. You don’t hire a poisoner to clean up your water supply. And most of all — most of all — you don’t hire someone who pits nature against jobs and jobs against health at a time when we so clearly need them all and we so clearly can have them all.”

11 thoughts on “Your Money Or Your Life???

  1. We have trash in the White House. It proves the point that people will sell their souls to have money, get money and stand beside someone who has money. It is only about acquisition and the delusions of grandeur which drive He-Who-Shall-Not-Be-Named. In retrospect the playground analogy is a good one. While growing up, each Fall I looked forward to a return to school, a fresh start and new possibilities. After awhile it became evident that the same old routine played out when the same people repeated the same scenarios as they grew. The bullies, the flirters to impress the bullies, the quiet watchers, the nerds and the unwitting victims who tried to hide in the shadows. I am not surprised by the statistics and percentages of vile humans willing to follow a gigantic bully because they have nothing real to offer themselves. Yet, it is time for the Watchers, the Nerds and the Victims to stand together and say NO. Are we helpless children? No. We are adults carrying the wisdom of our teachers and the truths we know in our hearts. We cannot sit back and cry “Foul!” but behave like helpless victims, giving up because someone says it is too late, it is impossible, or the odds are against us. Do the purveyors of hate and injustice care about odds? No, they deny them and shake their tiny fists in the face of odds. We have to be as diligent, as relentless and as devoted to our vision as they are to destroying it. Thanks for your words of wisdom. Some days I really have trouble hanging on. 😞


    • That, my friend, is the $6 million question! I can’t understand it at all. They will listen to the likes of Donald Trump and Jerry Falwell, but they won’t listen to people with brains who use facts as the basis for their arguments. Sigh.


  2. Jill, Thomas Friedman is a well-respected economics author (“The World is Flat” and “That used to be us” to name two). His is a voice of reason. Yet, voices of reason are not listened to, Bob Woodward has won two Pulitzer Prizes and he is not liatened to. Long time conservative pundits – George Will, David Brooks, Eric Erickson, Michael Gerson – are not listened. A person who is a prolific liar has convinced his followers everyone else is lying, even these voices of reason.


    Liked by 1 person

    • Agreed on both points, that Friedman is a voice worth listening to, and that a portion of people won’t bother to listen, just as they don’t listen to the others you name. And yet, we all still try to get them to listen, for our lives depend on it. Sigh.


  3. Good post. But when you have 40% of our citizens who simply don’t care and are ignorant and morally corrupt, I don’t hold out much hope. I was thinking what responsibility, if any, do the other 60% of us have for letting that 40% number get that high.

    Did we not insist enough, over the years, on good education, paying teachers much better to get the quality, having our media not just focus on the hot button two or three issues but the many other important ones, getting people the means to travel outside the US more, to get a worldview, making science more fun and understandable, emphasizing humanism more to counter religious extremism etc.?
    I don’t have the answer and there may not be one, but there is a reason here and even though right wing media like Fox is surely largely to blame, there is more to this. After all, they made a choice to even watch Fox or listen to Rush Limbaugh, in the first place, so it started before that.

    Liked by 2 people

    • You raise some good points, Mary. We have largely taken many of our freedoms and democratic processes for granted, assuming that they would always be there and not keeping up by changing as the world itself was changing. We lag now in education, health care, and many other fields because we maintained the status quo without moving forward very much. Let’s hope it isn’t too late for us to learn from our mistakes, and let’s hope that Joe Biden and his administration will be able to find ways to unify instead of divide the people of this nation.

      Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.