A Sensible Republican — Last Of A Dying Breed

The day of the sensible, reasonable, intelligent Republican seems to be long gone.  Way back when, I’ve even voted for Republicans, but I cannot picture ever doing so again, for the party has devolved into something ugly … a bunch who would rather burn down this nation than compromise, than meet Democrats on some middle ground.  John Boehner was one of the last Republicans for whom I had a great deal of respect, though I often disagreed with him.  He has written a book, due out on Tuesday, April 13th, that I have pre-ordered and plan to read.  What follows is an excerpt from that book, and I think you’ll be surprised when you read some of his words.

In the 2010 midterm election, voters from all over the place gave President Obama what he himself called “a shellacking.” And oh boy, was it ever. You could be a total moron and get elected just by having an R next to your name—and that year, by the way, we did pick up a fair number in that category.

Retaking control of the House of Representatives put me in line to be the next Speaker of the House over the largest freshman Republican class in history: 87 newly elected members of the GOP. Since I was presiding over a large group of people who’d never sat in Congress, I felt I owed them a little tutorial on governing. I had to explain how to actually get things done. A lot of that went straight through the ears of most of them, especially the ones who didn’t have brains that got in the way. Incrementalism? Compromise? That wasn’t their thing. A lot of them wanted to blow up Washington. That’s why they thought they were elected.

Some of them, well, you could tell they weren’t paying attention because they were just thinking of how to fundraise off of outrage or how they could get on Hannity that night. Ronald Reagan used to say something to the effect that if I get 80 or 90 percent of what I want, that’s a win. These guys wanted 100 percent every time. In fact, I don’t think that would satisfy them, because they didn’t really want legislative victories. They wanted wedge issues and conspiracies and crusades.

To them, my talk of trying to get anything done made me a sellout, a dupe of the Democrats, and a traitor. Some of them had me in their sights from day one. They saw me as much of an “enemy” as the guy in the White House. Me, a guy who had come to the top of the leadership by exposing corruption and pushing conservative ideas. Now I was a “liberal collaborator.” So that took some getting used to. What I also had not anticipated was the extent to which this new crowd hated—and I mean hated—Barack Obama.

By 2011, the right-wing propaganda nuts had managed to turn Obama into a toxic brand for conservatives. When I was first elected to Congress, we didn’t have any propaganda organization for conservatives, except maybe a magazine or two like National Review. The only people who used the internet were some geeks in Palo Alto. There was no Drudge Report. No Breitbart. No kooks on YouTube spreading dangerous nonsense like they did every day about Obama.

“He’s a secret Muslim!”

“He hates America!”

“He’s a communist!”

And of course the truly nutty business about his birth certificate. People really had been brainwashed into believing Barack Obama was some Manchurian candidate planning to betray America.

Mark Levin was the first to go on the radio and spout off this crazy nonsense. It got him ratings, so eventually he dragged Hannity and Rush to Looneyville along with him. My longtime friend Roger Ailes, the head of Fox News, was not immune to this. He got swept into the conspiracies and the paranoia and became an almost unrecognizable figure.

I’d known Ailes for a long time, since his work with George H.W. Bush in the early 1990s. He’d gone to college in Ohio, and since we had that connection, he sought me out at some event and introduced himself. Years later, in August of 1996, when I was in San Diego for the Republican National Convention, I ended up having dinner with Ailes and a veteran broadcasting executive named Rupert Murdoch. At that dinner they told me all about this new TV network they were starting. I had no idea I was listening to the outline of something that would make my life a living hell down the line. Sure enough, that October, Fox News hit the airwaves.

I kept in touch with Roger and starting in the early 2000s, I’d stop in and see him whenever I was in New York for fundraisers. We’d shoot the breeze and talk politics. We got to know each other pretty well.

Murdoch, on the other hand, was harder to know. Sometimes he’d invite me to watch the Super Bowl in the Fox box, or he’d stop by the office. Wherever he was, you could tell he was the man in charge. He was a businessman, pure and simple. He cared about ratings and the bottom line. He also wanted to make sure he was ahead of any political or policy developments coming down the line. He was always asking who was up, who was down, what bills could pass and what couldn’t. If he entertained any of the kooky conspiracy theories that started to take over his network, he kept it a secret from me. But he clearly didn’t have a problem with them if they helped ratings.

At some point after the 2008 election, something changed with my friend Roger Ailes. I once met him in New York during the Obama years to plead with him to put a leash on some of the crazies he was putting on the air. It was making my job trying to accomplish anything conservative that much harder. I didn’t expect this meeting to change anything, but I still thought it was bullshit, and I wanted Roger to know it.

When I put it to him like that, he didn’t have much to say. But he did go on and on about the terrorist attack on the U.S. Embassy in Benghazi, which he thought was part of a grand conspiracy that led back to Hillary Clinton. Then he outlined elaborate plots by which George Soros and the Clintons and Obama (and whoever else came to mind) were trying to destroy him.

“They’re monitoring me,” he assured me about the Obama White House. He told me he had a “safe room” built so he couldn’t be spied on. His mansion was being protected by combat-ready security personnel, he said. There was a lot of conspiratorial talk. It was like he’d been reading whacked-out spy novels all weekend.

And it was clear that he believed all of this crazy stuff. I walked out of that meeting in a daze. I just didn’t believe the entire federal government was so terrified of Roger Ailes that they’d break about a dozen laws to bring him down. I thought I could get him to control the crazies, and instead I found myself talking to the president of the club. One of us was crazy. Maybe it was me.

I have no idea what the relationship between Ailes and Murdoch was like, or if Ailes ever would go off on these paranoid tangents during meetings with his boss. But Murdoch must have thought Ailes was good for business, because he kept him in his job for years.

Places like Fox News were creating the wrong incentives. Sean Hannity was one of the worst. I’d known him for years, and we used to have a good relationship. But then he decided he felt like busting my ass every night on his show. So one day, in January of 2015, I finally called him and asked: “What the hell?” I wanted to know why he kept bashing House Republicans when we were actually trying to stand up to Obama.

“Well, you guys don’t have a plan,” he whined.

“Look,” I told him, “our plan is pretty simple: we’re just going to stand up for what we believe in as Republicans.”

I guess that wasn’t good enough for him. The conversation didn’t progress very far. At some point I called him a nut. Anyway, it’s safe to say our relationship never got any better.

Besides the homegrown “talent” at Fox, with their choice of guests they were making people who used to be fringe characters into powerful media stars. One of the first prototypes out of their laboratory was a woman named Michele Bachmann.

Bachmann, who had represented Minnesota’s 6th Congressional District since 2007 and made a name for herself as a lunatic ever since, came to meet with me in the busy period in late 2010 after the election. She wanted a seat on the Ways and Means Committee, the most powerful committee in the House. There were many members in line ahead of her for a post like this. People who had waited patiently for their turn and who also, by the way, weren’t wild-eyed crazies.

There was no way she was going to get on Ways and Means, the most prestigious committee in Congress, and jump ahead of everyone else in line. Not while I was Speaker. In earlier days, a member of Congress in her position wouldn’t even have dared ask for something like this. Sam Rayburn would have laughed her out of the city.

So I told her no—diplomatically, of course. But as she kept on talking, it dawned on me. This wasn’t a request of the Speaker of the House. This was a demand.

Her response to me was calm and matter-of-fact. “Well, then I’ll just have to go talk to Sean Hannity and everybody at Fox,” she said, “and Rush Limbaugh, Mark Levin, and everybody else on the radio, and tell them that this is how John Boehner is treating the people who made it possible for the Republicans to take back the House.”

I wasn’t the one with the power, she was saying. I just thought I was. She had the power now.

She was right, of course.

She was a conservative media darling and, by then, the conservative media was already eyeing me skeptically. She had me where it hurt. Even if I wanted to help her, and I sure as hell didn’t, it wasn’t a decision I had the power to make on my own. That power belongs to a little-known but very important group called the Steering Committee.

I knew there was no way the Steering Committee would approve putting Bachmann on Ways and Means. The votes just weren’t there. If I even pushed the issue, they wouldn’t have let me leave the meeting without fastening me into a straitjacket. But then, Bachmann wouldn’t go on TV and the radio to explain the nuances of House Steering Committee procedure. She’d just rip my head off every night, over and over again. That was a headache I frankly didn’t want or need.

I suggested the House Intelligence committee to Bachmann as an alternative, and mercifully, she liked it. It would be a good perch for anyone wanting to build up their foreign policy chops for a run for president, which she was already considering— Lord help us all. None too pleased was the man preparing to take up the gavel as chairman of the Intelligence Committee, Rep. Mike Rogers from Michigan, an army veteran who had also served in the FBI. So I took my lumps from Rogers, and Bachmann took her seat on the committee.

The funny thing is, Michele Bachmann turned out to be a very focused, hardworking member—even though she spent a few months later in 2011 on a short-lived campaign for president. She showed up to the committee, did her homework, and ended up winning over her fellow members with her dedication. Mike Rogers was impressed—and I have to admit, so was I. The whole situation ended up working out well for everyone. As one of those old Boehnerisms goes, “Get the right people on the bus, and help them find the right seat.”

In January 2011, as the new Republican House majority was settling in and I was getting adjusted to the Speakership, I was asked about the birth certificate business by Brian Williams of NBC News. My answer was simple: “The state of Hawaii has said that President Obama was born there. That’s good enough for me.” It was a simple statement of fact. But you would have thought I’d called Ronald Reagan a communist. I got all kinds of shit for it—emails, letters, phone calls. It went on for a couple weeks. I knew we would hear from some of the crazies, but I was surprised at just how many there really were.

All of this crap swirling around was going to make it tough for me to cut any deals with Obama as the new House Speaker. Of course, it has to be said that Obama didn’t help himself much either. He could come off as lecturing and haughty. He still wasn’t making Republican outreach a priority. But on the other hand—how do you find common cause with people who think you are a secret Kenyan Muslim traitor to America?

Under the new rules of Crazytown, I may have been Speaker, but I didn’t hold all the power. By 2013 the chaos caucus in the House had built up their own power base thanks to fawning right-wing media and outrage-driven fundraising cash. And now they had a new head lunatic leading the way, who wasn’t even a House member. There is nothing more dangerous than a reckless asshole who thinks he is smarter than everyone else. Ladies and gentlemen, meet Senator Ted Cruz. He enlisted the crazy caucus of the GOP in what was a truly dumbass idea. Not that anybody asked me.

22 thoughts on “A Sensible Republican — Last Of A Dying Breed

  1. sounds like an interesting book, I may give it a read myself.
    Thanks for bringing it to our attention. I hope you have a good Easter my friend. hugs.

    Liked by 2 people

    • I said the same a few years back, that I could see parallels between 1933 Germany and present-day U.S. I had hoped that we learned our lesson under the former guy’s reign of cruelty, but apparently not. Sigh.

      Liked by 2 people

    • So am I, dear friend. I am struggling to find a reason to exist, as I have given up any hope that what I’m doing makes a difference, or that anything I could do would make a difference. I’m too old and tired for all of this … and yet, I keep trying. Only explanation I know of is that I’m a fool. But, I am worn down, depressed, and tired of the fight. Sigh. Big HUGS.


  2. I don’t care for Boehner, but I can respect his opinion here. The far right has moved all the way to crazy town.

    I told someone the other day, who didn’t know, and were I think wondering, that “hey! I’m a lefty!” Which eased their immediate concerns. 🙂 But I had to reiterate later, that I’m really more of a centrist. It’s just that the right has moved so far into crazy town, that I’m now a lefty by default. I have voted R in the past. Probably never will again at this point. The R party, if they ever had any decency at all, it’s pretty much gone now. I doubt we will see it return until the party implodes and has to be rebuilt from scratch.

    That, or the next time they are in power they have a less incompetent fool in charge, capable of pulling off the coup.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Compared to today’s crop of Republican legislators, Boehner looks almost like a Democrat! He at least tried to do his job, rather than parading about spewing conspiracy theories to entice his base.

      Like you, I am neither a Democrat nor Republican and have voted for both in my lifetime, but I cannot picture myself ever voting for another Republican, given the new ideologies and behaviours of the party. In fact, I hope that since they are refusing to reconsider their hateful, bigoted platform (such as it is), they crash and burn, perhaps something good can rise from the ashes.


  3. From where I sit, it seems pretty clear that the ‘obama problem’ is racist inspired, pure and simple. I for one hope that the republican party has had its day — because if it hasn’t, that doesn’t bode well for anyone.

    Liked by 3 people

    • Since day #1 I said it was racist inspired. I even had friends who referred to him not as ‘President’, not even as ‘Obama’, but as “that Black man” or “Nobama” or worse yet, the N-word. Uppity, they called him! They fell for the lie that he wasn’t born in the U.S. (until I asked them if they didn’t realize that Hawaii is a state in the U.S.) They criticized his and his wife’s clothing choices and everything else they could think of. Many … most of them are no longer friends, for my patience ran out. I am hoping to see the GOP go down in flames, for they see that they are in the minority, yet rather than try to alter their ideologies, they would rather take away our right to vote.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Do we call this media politics? The media controls the political storyline. Robert Murdoch got an idea into his head, probably in cahoots with the Koch brothers. If they control print, radio, and broadcast media they can control the whole English-speaking world. Their chickens are now coming home to lay their eggs. Government is no longer political, but adversarial. There can be no more compromise. This is the age of the conservative Media Bully!

    Liked by 4 people

    • You are largely right in your assessment. But, the only ones who can stop this madness is … us. When we educate ourselves and stop listening to the media hyperbole, then perhaps they will learn their lesson and report news instead of propaganda.


  5. Jill, I agree with your assertion. I disagreed with John Boehner on a number of fronts, but he worked to get some things done, often getting enough Republican votes to side with the Democrats. He knew this was the only way to get needed legislation through the Democrat led Senate. My main disagreement with him was not discussing an Immigration bill that passed the Senate led by a bipartisan group of eight Senators. This led to a DACA executive action, when it easily could have been avoided. In this case, he followed the party line that it would be more valuable politically not to pass a bill. And, we still suffer from that decision. Keith

    Liked by 4 people

    • Yes, he was more concerned about actually doing his job than just playing to the masses, and for that I respected him. Did you know, he lives only about 2 miles from me? His, of course, is a gated community to keep us from down here in da ‘hood out! 😉 And I agree with you on the immigration issue, but frankly, I think it would have been shredded by the former guy anyway. We will long pay the price for the years 2017-2020.


      • Jill, interesting. Maybe you can borrow a cup of flour? As for the immigration issue, it would have negated the need for DACA, so a the former president who just left would have needed a law to change it. One more good thing about Boehner, he used is muscle to get one last needed bill through before handing the reins to Paul Ryan, who could not have done it. Keith


        • Hah! The section he lives in used to be the shortest distance between where I live and the business district, where the restaurants and shops are. But, the rich dudes didn’t like the “riff-raff” driving past their houses, so they ‘gated’ the community and closed it to through traffic.

          I used to rail against Boehner from time to time, but … everything is relative, and relative to the latest crop of Republicans, Boehner was a moderate. Which was his last bill?

          Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.