Enough is enough is enough! Many of us are, or were once, parents of toddlers. Remember how your toddler screamed and threw a fit, knowing he was either going to get whacked, get put in a corner for 10 minutes, or at the very least get yelled at, but still, he threw his tantrum? It has to do with the notion that any attention, even negative attention, is better than no attention. It is like the popular saying the “the squeaky wheel gets the oil”. I fully intended to write a blog post tonight that did not even so much as mention the t-word, which is hard enough, but then I saw the story about what happened today in Arizona and … well, here I am again.
For any who may not have seen the news today:
Protesters in Arizona blocked a major road leading to a Donald J. Trump rally on Saturday outside Phoenix, while anti-Trump demonstrators in New York clashed with the police on a march toward Trump Tower. (Rosenberg, New York Times, 19 March 2016)
In Arizona, about 50 to 75 protesters and three parked cars blocked Shea Boulevard, an artery leading into Fountain Hills, the suburb where Mr. Trump spoke on Saturday afternoon, which led to traffic delays in the area.
Some protesters chained themselves to the cars, according to a spokesman from the Maricopa County sheriff’s office. Others stood in the street, holding signs and chanting as the temperature climbed into the 80s and anxious drivers sat stuck in their cars.
After multiple requests that the protesters clear the road, sheriff’s deputies began towing cars, and three people were arrested.
“They tried to get us to move,” said one of the protesters, Tomás Robles Jr. “We told them we were not going to move.”
Eventually many of them began marching to the rally, but did not make it close to the stage. Instead they marched single file across a nearby lawn, then found themselves surrounded by sheriff’s deputies on horseback and all-terrain vehicles on one side, and Trump supporters on the other, chanting “U.S.A.! U.S.A.!”
When the rally began, the Maricopa County sheriff, Joe Arpaio — who like Mr. Trump has a hard-line stance on immigration, many fans and many critics — introduced the candidate and spoke briefly about the demonstrators.
“Because of them, we had to get a little more sunshine, but we made it,” Sheriff Arpaio said. “Three of them are in jail,” he added, to cheers.
In New York, several hundred protesters gathered at Columbus Circle outside the Trump International Hotel there. One brandished a sign that read, “No Wall Around the Land of the Free.” Another sign suggested a wall be built around Mr. Trump.
Gina Rodriguez, 28, of Harlem, said, “When Trump talks, I feel like he is targeting my community.”
The first conflicts took place just after 1:30 p.m. as the crowd sought to cross 59th Street and head south at the Avenue of the Americas. They chanted, “Dump Trump” and “Don’t give into racist fear.” A line of police officers, scooters and barricades blocked their way as some protesters shouted that they had the light. Then, after a countdown, a mass of protesters surged forward, with those behind digging their heels into the sidewalk and pushing with their shoulders against the demonstrators in front of them.
The police pushed back, and for about 10 minutes, the two sides formed a heaving scrum with metal barricades being used as fulcrums and both police officers and protesters losing their footing and tumbling to the ground. At one point, a stream of pepper spray came from the ranks of the police officers, sending protesters reeling back and rubbing their eyes.
A few moments later, the march toward Trump Tower resumed, with protesters chanting, waving signs and beating drums and occasionally darting into the roadway. They were followed by police officers in cars and on foot, including one carrying an acoustic device that issued recorded warnings that blocking vehicles could lead to arrest.
At least two protesters were grabbed by police officers and placed into handcuffs. When the crowd made it to Trump Tower, the police tried to herd them into a protest zone, but instead the protesters quickly moved on, with many of them heading back to Columbus Circle, where they resumed their chants.
While I dislike Trump more than I can ever remember disliking another living human being, and while I further support the right of all to peacefully protest, this behaviour is exactly what Trump wants. It is feeding his narcissistic ego and it is giving him the media exposure that he thrives on. He has made statement after statement to indicate this, and we are all feeding the frenzy, feeding the ego.
- “If you see somebody getting ready to throw a tomato, knock the crap out of ’em, would you? Seriously. Okay? Just knock the hell — I promise you, I will pay for the legal fees. I promise. I promise.” – Feb 1, Cedar Rapids, IA
- “Get him out. Try not to hurt him. If you do I’ll defend you in court.” “Are Trump rallies the most fun?” “We’re having a good time.” He then recalled an incident at a New Hampshire rally where a protester started “swinging and punching.” Trump said some people in the audience “took him out.” “It was really amazing to watch,” he said. – Mar 4, Warren, MI
- “See, in the good old days this didn’t use to happen, because they used to treat them very rough. We’ve become very weak.” – Mar 9, Fayetteville, NC
Trump has claimed that the protestors are being organized by Bernie Sanders. He later claimed that they were organized and paid for by Hillary Clinton. There is no evidence to support either of these suppositions, and it is just as likely that Trump, himself, is the force behind the protests. While he claims that he “does not condone” the violence at his rallies, the reality is that he not only condones it, but encourages it, as evidenced by the above quotes.
People have both a constitutional right (read 1st Amendment) and plenty of good reasons for protesting at Trump’s rallies. A week ago, I considered doing so myself, so I certainly understand. That said, it is not helping bring Trump down, it is not, as we think it should, proving to his supporters that he is, indeed, a maniacal fascist. Instead, it is having the opposite effect. It feeds his ego, but even worse, it gives him even wider media coverage, which, like the child I mentioned in the beginning, is attention. This candidate thrives on attention, whether positive or negative. How far can this madness go? I am not sure, but at the rate the violence surrounding his public appearances is escalating, I genuinely fear that it will eventually lead to serious injury and even death of innocent people. And I do not think that either Trump or his supporters would feel a moment’s regret. Sad, but true.
I call on people to use good judgment and stay away from Trump’s feeding frenzies. Do not lower yourself to the level of Trump and his supporters, but stand above them. Protest by writing letters to his campaign headquarters, protest by supporting other candidates, protest by some other means than showing up at his rallies. And I call on the media, especially the mainstream press, to significantly reduce the amount of coverage they give Trump and his “events”. I firmly believe that for a narcissistic personality like Trump, being ignored is a far worse punishment than any other.