The Boiling Frog

Most of the blogs I read on a semi-regular basis are political or historical in nature, but there are a handful that I try to catch once a week or so for their humour or feel-good value. Recently, our friends Ellen and Benjamin introduced me to a new one, Nuggets of Gold. Nuggets is usually humorous and/or uplifting. The blogger, Joy of Roses, is a very lovable lady, and about once a week I pop in there for a smile or two and a hug. Yesterday, however, she took on a more serious tone, just for the day, and wrote this post which I think puts into words something that most of us feel at a gut level but have tried to avoid voicing, rather like the elephant in the room. So, allow me to introduce you to Joy of Roses, and please think about her words … I hope they are not prophetic, but they are certainly reflective of our situation today. Thank you, Joy of Roses, for this well-written and thoughtful post and for your permission to share it.

Nuggets of Gold

543a8fdd4c2da63aa371d571bbc809ba

When I was in school and first studied about Hitler I remember feeling sickened by what I learned. It was mind boggling to me how a Country could let someone so evil take over power and do all the horrible things that he did!

What I grew to realize was that he wasn’t outright evil all at once. It was a growing thing. He didn’t call for the extermination of the Jews right away. He started slowly taking their rights away, and then encouraging people not to buy from them and so on. He persuaded people to believe that he was doing the right thing for the Country, that he would make Germany great again. He was disgruntled about how Germany was.

There are articles that say that his stare could be mesmerizing and intimidating and he would use that when making speeches and making eye contact with others. It…

View original post 379 more words

“That’s Our Hitler!”

Blogger-friend Erik Hare has knocked yet another one out of the ballpark. His analysis of the latest Trump budget, and I use the term ‘budget’ loosely, is spot on, I believe. Please take a moment to read Erik’s post … I guarantee it will give you some food for thought! Thank you, Erik, for a great post and for implicit permission to share!

Barataria - The work of Erik Hare

The moment comes about halfway through Mel Brooks’ brilliant 1968 movie “The Producers”. Max Bialystock is deep into his plot to stage the worst musical ever for the purpose of having it close after one performance. All he has to do is raise far more money than the flop could possibly take to stage and no one will ask for their share of the 25,000% of the profits which has been sold to investors. The worst musical ever, “Springtime for Hitler,” has been chosen. It’s now time to cast it.

Hippie Lorenzo Saint DuBois wanders into the casting call and gives his performance. As soon as he says, “If everyone in the world had a flower instead of a gun the world would be one big smell-in!” Bialystock rises triumphantly and declares, “That’s our Hitler!”

It’s the moment when simple comedy runs boldly over the line into farce and never…

View original post 596 more words

History Lessons

Blogger-friend Hugh Curtler is a reader and a thinker, as am I. But Hugh takes it a step farther, as he is able to see parallels that I, frankly, would miss. Often he finds those parallels in history and literature that reflect our situation today, and once again he has done so. We tend to think, not only here in the U.S., but also around the globe, that the world we are living in today is unique, that such political turmoil and angst belongs to this time and place alone. But, as Hugh has once again pointed out, history is cyclic, and the world has seen similar conditions in the past. Why does this matter, you ask? It matters because there are lessons to be learned from the mistakes of the past. And if we apply those lessons, perhaps we can avoid some of the mistakes from long ago. So, I share this excellent post by Hugh in hopes that we can all learn from a bit of ancient history. Thank you, Hugh, for your insight and for allowing me to share it.

hughcurtler

After Athens and Sparta led the Greeks in battle against the mammoth forces of Persia and won the battle of Marathon — where Herodotus estimates that they were outnumbered as much as 10 to 1, the Greeks formed the Delian league which exacted tribute from the various Greek City-States too help build Greek forces against possible future attacks. The funds were kept at Delos, home of the Delphic Oracle and a place sacred to the Greeks.

Eventually, Athens transferred the money to Athens and used it to help them build their navy and arm their forces (and the Parthenon), while assuming control of many of the City-Sates that were weaker than they. Indeed, the Athenians thought it only natural that the stronger should take control of the weaker. And, oddly enough, the rest of the Greeks seem to have adopted that view as well — even the weak ones! But eventually…

View original post 650 more words

It’s Not MY Fault!

Back in the day when my children were young, I came to understand that my middle child, my son M, had a problem accepting responsibility for his own actions.  I should have understood this when he was around four years old and had been outside playing with his sister and friends.  He came rushing into the house and breathlessly exclaimed “whatever they say I did, I didn’t do it!”  This should have thrown up a major red flag, but instead, I laughed it off.  Later, when he was in high school and failing miserably in one class, he said it was not his fault, it was the fault of the teacher.  My daughter had taken the same class under the same teacher the year before and done very well, but M swore that the teacher had “something against [him]”.  By this time, I was beginning to see a pattern, but was not quite sure what to do about it.  The final straw came when he came home drunk one night at about the age of sixteen.  He had been out with an older cousin, and when I began to read him the riot act, he said to me “mom, it isn’t my fault! It was D’s (the cousin) fault!”  I asked if his cousin had held him down and forced alcohol into him.  Long story short, it finally came around to him telling me it was my fault for letting him go somewhere with his cousin, that I should have known this would happen.  It was at that point that I fully realized this child of mine never accepted responsibility for a single one of his own actions.

Being a fairly private person, I do not often share stories of my family life, but I shared that one because I think it is very apropos of what is happening today with in the Trump campaign. Following a week marked by his controversial comments, and reversals, Trump called for Governor Kasich to resign from the race, claiming that Kasich, the winner of only his home state’s primary, had no right to continue on the campaign trail accumulating delegates if he has no chance of becoming the nominee. “He doesn’t have to run and take my votes,” he said.  It never occurs to him that he is losing “his” votes by his misogynistic rhetoric, his disjointed, ignorant responses to serious questions, the fact that he sanctions hatred and violence in nearly every speech makes.  No, for that would mean accepting responsibility, and he will not do that.  If he loses Wisconsin today, which seems inevitable, he has already made it clear that he will blame talk radio hosts for his failure, he will blame Governor Kasich for his failure, he will probably find a way to blame women for his failure.  But the one person he will not blame is himself, the only person truly responsible for his failure.  “In certain areas — the city areas — I’m not doing well. I’m not doing well because nobody knows my message. They were given misinformation.”

Trump’s refusal to accept responsibility is only one symptom of a greater disease, one that I mentioned in a post just last week – he is a classic narcissist.  Narcissists tend to be quite adept at attracting followers. They are spontaneous and free from constraints, and think they are invincible. As a narcissist grows in power, he disregards advice from his subordinates and does not try to persuade those who disagree with him but instead he ignores them, or has them deposed or otherwise gotten rid of. Narcissists are defined by a sensitivity to criticism, being a poor listener, and a lack of empathy toward others.  (Burgemeester, The Narcissistic Life, 01 April 2013).  Need I say more?

Just like my son, Trump’s antics and bluster were at first humorous, producing a clown-like character that nobody took very seriously.  Unfortunately, he began attracting followers, people who wanted so badly to believe in his message, wanted to believe that here was a man who could actually “make America great again”, that they did not ask questions, did not expect answers.  He knew the buttons to push, the strings to pull, and his following grew, even further inflating his ego to the point where he claimed “I have the most loyal people, did you ever see that? I could stand in the middle of 5th Avenue and shoot people and I wouldn’t lose voters.”

Trump hurt his image among women last week by his cruel and thoughtless comments that women should be punished for having abortions.  He hurt his image among intellectuals and scholars long before.  It is time, however, for all to awaken from the spell Trump has cast and clearly see what he is.  He has had nine months to learn about foreign policy, nine months during which he could have listened to advisors, studied the situations in the Middle East, Europe and Asia, and developed at least a moderate understanding.  Instead, he chose to spend his time tooting his horn, the result being that in two interviews last week, he was unable to answer a single question about foreign affairs.  He suggests that the U.S. needs to distance itself from NATO, yet he does not understand the scope and purpose of NATO.  This is the danger that is Trump. Muammar Qaddafi, Adolf Hitler, Pol Pot, and Joseph Stalin are examples of leaders with narcissistic personalities. Narcissists become dictators, rarely leaders of a democratic nation.

I said in a recent post that I do not believe Trump actually wants the job as President of the United States.  I firmly believe that, and the evidence is mounting.  I certainly hope I am right.  Meanwhile, I call upon … nay, I challenge anybody who still believes in Trump, to read the transcript of his interview with the Washington Post or the New York Times (links provided below) and count the times that what he says or how he says it closely ties to the traits of a narcissist.

Transcript for New York Times interview

Transcript for Washington Post interview

I Beg of You … Please Read This!

Okay folks, now I am mad!  And when Filosofa gets mad, let the sparks fly.

  • At a campaign event in Birmingham, Ala., on Saturday, Nov. 21 2015, Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump demands the removal of a well-known activist Mercutio Southall Jr. after he shouts, “Black lives matter!” (Reuters) Trump’s response: “maybe he should have been roughed up.” At one point, Southall fell to the ground and was surrounded by several white men who appeared to be kicking and punching him, according to video captured by CNN.  Southall was apparently shouting “black lives matter” and “dump the Trump” amidst the crowd, and was wearing a BLM (Black Lives Matter) shirt.
  • Donald Trump supporters shout racial slurs, Nazi salute at protester in Las Vegas rally: ‘It felt like a mob’. (New York Times, Dec. 15, 2015) As the guards drag the heckler out, protesters are heard yelling “Shoot him!” and “Kick his a–!”  One man caught on camera barks the Nazi salute, “Sieg heil!” and appears to shoot his right hand into the air.

In neither of these cases did Trump do or say anything to stop the brutality, nor did he express regret or remorse.

Where did the First Amendment Freedom of Speech get de-railed?  Southall was protesting Donald Trump, a political candidate who has exhibited racism, bigotry and pure hatred in the past.  Whether you are a Trump supporter or not, whether you support the #Black Lives Matter movement or not, is all irrelevant for the purposes of this conversation.  The only things that matter here are the facts.  The facts are that Mr. Southall and others were protesting, peacefully, and he was beaten and cursed, actions which were lauded by the candidate Trump and his supporters.

In the 1930’s, Adolph Hitler, an unlikely candidate, a racist and a bigot, rose to the highest power in the German nation.  The main reason he was able to do so was because the German people were sick and tired of the status quo.  War bonds that had been sold to the German people to finance the war were now worthless.  Food and other resources had been diverted to the war effort.  Germany was struggling under the burden of war debt, and then came the Treaty of Versailles.  Harsh reparations had been imposed on the nation for its role in World War I and the German people were suffering greatly as a result.  Jobs were scarce, food was scarce.  In addition, there was a worldwide economic depression.  The German people had lost confidence in their government, the Weimar Republic, to be able to help them through these times.  The environment was fertile for the rise in power of the Nazi party. Although not particularly well-educated, Hitler’s oratory skills and anti-Semitism gained him the spotlight where he caught the eye of the DAP, the German Worker’s Party.  He attracted large numbers of Germans who were disenchanted and desperate for change … any change from the status quo.  The Nazis appealed especially to the young, unemployed and members of the lower middle class.  To make a long story short, because this is a blog post and not a history book, Hitler rode the wave of popular support to the Chancellorship of the German nation.  Was there opposition to his bigotry, his anti-Semitism?  Sure, but they were not successful, as they were rapidly silenced by Hitler’s thugs, his bodyguards, the thugs known as the Stormtroopers or Brown Shirts, who got their start defending his rallies.  They “roughed up” people who protested or disagreed with Hitler, they pushed, shoved and threw out his rivals.

Does some of this sound familiar?  Hitler believed in the superiority of white-skinned nationalists, just as does Trump. Hitler was actually a more polished speaker than Trump, but the message was basically the same.  Hitler swore to restore Germany to its previous glory, as Trump is promising to do for the U.S. today, and Hitler brooked no resistance, no protests, tolerated nobody who disagreed with his policies and methods, just as Trump today.  In 1930’s Germany, the people were tired, they were angry, they wanted change … any change and seemingly at any cost, just as the American people of the 21st century.  Hitler was a bigot, a racist and a cruel dictator.  Donald trump is no different.  The difference is that we will be holding free elections in just under ten months and we have the freedom to choose.  If you think that the Constitution and our democratic system of government will prevent Donald Trump from becoming the ruthless dictator that Adolph Hitler became some 83 years ago, think again.  Donald Trump does not want to be the president of a democratic nation where he works in conjunction with two other branches of government to implement policies for the good of the nation.  Donald Trump intends to rule the nation with an iron fist and if the people of the United States do not wake up and realize the danger this man poses, he may get the opportunity to do just that.

It started with Mr. Southall, or even before him, but unless We The People put a stop to it, it will not end there. I am waiting for Mr. Trump to come to my city.  I will be there, I will be wearing my BLM shirt, and I will not be quiet.  Let Mr. T sic his thugs on me, and the next day let the headlines read “65 year-old woman brutally beaten by Trump bodyguards as Trump says “she probably deserved it, crazy old bitch”!  I will have gone down fighting for what I actually believe in, fighting for what is right.  Some things are worth fighting for, worth giving your life for, and if we forget that, then yes, we deserve what we get.

Are We Doomed to Repeat the Past?

History is indeed cyclical and history does sometimes repeat itself, despite our best efforts to learn from the past. There are a number of not-so-shining examples around the globe today that may ultimately prove this point.

  1. With anti-Semitism seemingly on the rise in much of Europe, Adolph Hitler’s Mein Kampf is being re-published (the new version is 2,000 pages compared to the 800 page original) and it is reported that the German Teachers Union is in support of the new, annotated edition being used in German schools.  I am conflicted about the re-publication of the book, as I certainly do not advocate the banning of books, however I am not eager to see this book on shelves at my local bookseller.  I don’t think there is any danger of your average citizen grabbing it up and adopting the ideology of Hitler.  However, I do not see a reason to re-publish the book in the first place … it is nothing more than a treatise on anti-Semitism … and I am thoroughly against using it as a teaching tool or as required reading in schools.  When I hear the phrase “we will not forget”, whether in reference to the Holocaust, Pearl Harbor, 9/11, or any other historic episode, I wonder whether that is true.  Certainly those of us who lived through any of those events will never forget, but what about future generations?  Has enough time passed that we have actually forgotten the lessons of Hitler’s domination and of the Holocaust?  Very few Holocaust survivors are still alive today, and those are 70+ years old.  In another twenty years, there will be none left to remind us.  Certainly there are enough books and films, but is that enough?  Is it possible that we might forget the lessons and be lured once again into the mentality of bigotry, narcissism and racism that was Hitler’s dark legacy?  I hope not, but I am not sure.  To use Mein Kampf in teaching school children seems a recipe for disaster.  Despite an overall decrease in the number of members of “official” neo-Nazi groups in Europe, neo-Nazi propaganda and activities have nearly doubled in the last three years. (Felicity Capon, Newsweek, 24 March 2015)
  2. It is becoming increasingly obvious that Vladimir Putin, President of Russia and a former KGB officer, is working toward a goal of resurrecting an empire similar to the USSR of yore.  In an address to the nation in April 2005, he is quoted as saying “ …we should acknowledge that the collapse of the Soviet Union was a major geopolitical disaster of the century.” In March 2014, Putin annexed Crimea, then a part of the Ukraine, saying that “Crimea has always been and remains an inseparable part of Russia”. He has also made statements that Ukraine and Russia are “one nation” on more than one occasion.  More recently, in September 2015, Putin lent military aid to support the crumbling al Assad regime in Syria.  (Colum Lynch, Foreign Policy, 7 October 2015).  Due to falling oil prices, the Russian economy is already crumbling, and yet Putin has somehow seen fit to involve his country in the war in Syria.  One must ask the question:  WHY?  It is a situation that bears watching.
  3. At here in the U.S., racism is yet again on the front lines.  A 2015 poll conducted by the Kaiser Family Foundation in conjunction with CNN found that 49% see racism as a big problem, as compared to just 28% four years ago.  Another 33% see it as “somewhat” of a problem, while only 12% think it is either a small problem, not a problem at all, or don’t know/don’t care.  Meanwhile, Donald Trump’s rhetoric in his bid for president seems to have given a boost to white supremacist groups such as Stormfront, a white supremacist group referring to themselves as “white nationalists”.  Much of today’s racism against African-Americans can be seen in events such as the murder of Trayvon Martin and the exoneration of his killer under Florida’s ‘Stand Your Ground’ law, the killing of Michael Brown by a police officer in Ferguson, Missouri, the death of Freddie Gray while in police custody in Baltimore, Maryland as well as numerous others. The question becomes, are these events a cause of increased racism, or the effect?  I do not know the answer to that question, but before it goes any further, lawmakers, police departments and courts need to analyze and, in the words of Donald Trump, “figure out what’s going on”.  We cannot tolerate a return to the racist environment of the Civil Rights era, and that appears to be precisely where we are heading.

None of the above examples, taken at face value, indicate a return to the past.  There is still a long way to go until a neo-Nazi party comes to power in a European nation, or the Soviet empire returns to power in Eastern Europe, or the United States returns to the Civil Rights era of the 1950’s-1960’s.  But these are indicators that the winds may be blowing in that direction and I think it is prudent to realize this, be ever-vigilant and carefully elect leaders who will use their power to stop any further progression toward a return to a past that holds nothing but shame … a past that is made of “we will never forget” moments.